How these scores work

Every fit score is computed from this site’s card data by a fixed, published formula: four weighted components (earn in the category, welcome bonus, annual fee, ease of qualifying) add up to 100. On this page the earn yardstick is its Air Canada earn rate, since that is the category every Aeroplan card bonuses. Point values are the typical redemption values from our reward values reference, the same ones every other score on the site uses. Click any score to open its breakdown. The card score column beside it is a different number: how the card stands against every card of its type across seven components, from the full rankings. The two are expected to disagree, because one measures a job and the other measures the whole card. How both scores are built.

Best for occasional Air Canada flyers

Mid-tier and entry cards that earn Aeroplan without a premium fee. The right pick if you fly Air Canada once or twice a year and want points plus a free checked bag.

#CardFit scoreCard scoreAnnual feeWhy it ranks here
1 American Express Aeroplan Card Apply →No income gate
62math
Earn+21 / 45
2x the airline × 1.4¢ = 2.8% effective
Welcome+10.5 / 20
45,000 pts ≈ $630
Fee+16 / 20
$120 annual fee
Access+15 / 15
No income requirement
Score62 / 100
34.120th of 24 mid-tier $120 2x Aeroplan on Air Canada, 1.5x on dining and food delivery, and a free checked bag, with no income bar.
2 CIBC Aeroplan Visa Infinite$60K income
53math
Earn+15.7 / 45
1.5x the airline × 1.4¢ = 2.1% effective
Welcome+11.7 / 20
50,000 pts ≈ $700
Fee+15.4 / 20
$139 annual fee
Access+10.5 / 15
$60K personal income
Score53 / 100
44.610th of 24 mid-tier $139 Same earn as the TD Infinite, with the annual fee rebated for CIBC Smart chequing account holders.
3 TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite Apply →$60K income
53math
Earn+15.7 / 45
1.5x the airline × 1.4¢ = 2.1% effective
Welcome+11.7 / 20
50,000 pts ≈ $700
Fee+15.4 / 20
$139 annual fee
Access+10.5 / 15
$60K personal income
Score53 / 100
43.812th of 24 mid-tier $139 The default Air Canada card: 1.5x on groceries, gas, and AC, a free checked bag, and a Nexus credit.
4 TD Aeroplan Visa Platinum Apply →No income gate
47math
Earn+10.5 / 45
1x the airline × 1.4¢ = 1.4% effective
Welcome+4.7 / 20
20,000 pts ≈ $280
Fee+17 / 20
$89 annual fee
Access+15 / 15
No income requirement
Score47 / 100
31.223rd of 24 mid-tier $89 The lowest-fee Aeroplan card and the only one with no income test. A weak base earn is the trade-off.

Best for frequent flyers

Premium cards with lounge access, the highest Air Canada earn, and a companion pass or status acceleration. These earn their keep if you fly several times a year.

#CardFit scoreCard scoreAnnual feeWhy it ranks here
1 American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card Apply →No income gate
66math
Earn+31.5 / 45
3x the airline × 1.4¢ = 4.2% effective
Welcome+19.8 / 20
85,000 pts ≈ $1,190
Fee+0 / 20
$599 annual fee
Access+15 / 15
No income requirement
Score66 / 100
63.59th of 9 premium $599 Unlimited Maple Leaf Lounge access when flying AC, a Priority Pass, 3x Aeroplan on Air Canada, and no income bar.
2 TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege Apply →$150K income
46math
Earn+21 / 45
2x the airline × 1.4¢ = 2.8% effective
Welcome+20 / 20
100,000 pts ≈ $1,400
Fee+0 / 20
$599 annual fee
Access+4.5 / 15
$150K personal income
Score46 / 100
67.67th of 9 premium $599 Unlimited Maple Leaf Lounge with a guest, an annual companion pass, a Nexus credit, and 2x on AC.
3 CIBC Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege$150K income
46math
Earn+21 / 45
2x the airline × 1.4¢ = 2.8% effective
Welcome+20 / 20
100,000 pts ≈ $1,400
Fee+0 / 20
$599 annual fee
Access+4.5 / 15
$150K personal income
Score46 / 100
67.08th of 9 premium $599 Identical earn and lounge access to the TD Privilege, with up to $139 of the fee rebated via CIBC Smart Plus.
Read the business guide →

Lounge access and the companion pass

The three premium cards score within two points of each other on earn and fee, so the real split is what they include beyond points. The Amex Aeroplan Reserve gives unlimited Maple Leaf Lounge access whenever you fly Air Canada, plus a Priority Pass for non-Air-Canada lounges, and it asks for no minimum income. The TD and CIBC Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege cards also include unlimited Maple Leaf Lounge access with a guest, but they gate it behind a $150,000 income requirement. If you can clear that bar, the choice between TD and CIBC comes down to the companion pass and fee rebate, not the points.

Both Visa Infinite Privilege cards carry an annual companion pass: a round-trip companion fare from a set base price plus taxes once you hit an annual spend threshold. CIBC layers on a Smart Plus rebate that can cut the $599 fee to roughly $460 if you hold the chequing account. The Reserve has no companion pass, but its lounge access is the most generous and the most accessible, which is why it leads the premium tier here.

Read the comparison →
Read the case study →

Common questions

What is the best Aeroplan credit card in Canada?

It depends on how often you fly. For occasional Air Canada flyers, the American Express Aeroplan Card tops our mid-tier ranking: 2x Aeroplan on Air Canada, 1.5x on dining, a free checked bag, and no income requirement, for $120. For frequent flyers who want lounge access, the American Express Aeroplan Reserve leads the premium tier with unlimited Maple Leaf Lounge access and 3x on Air Canada, for $599. Business owners are ranked separately in our best Aeroplan business credit card guide above.

Which Aeroplan card has no income requirement?

The American Express Aeroplan Card and American Express Aeroplan Reserve have no published minimum personal income requirement, unlike the TD and CIBC Aeroplan Visa Infinite cards, which require $60,000, and their Visa Infinite Privilege versions, which require $150,000. Among personal cards the TD Aeroplan Visa Platinum also carries no stated minimum and is the lowest-fee entry point at $89.

Is the Amex Aeroplan Reserve worth the $599 annual fee?

If you fly Air Canada several times a year, the unlimited Maple Leaf Lounge access alone can justify the fee, since single lounge passes run roughly $50 each. The Reserve also includes a Priority Pass, 3x Aeroplan on Air Canada, and no income requirement. If you fly only once or twice a year, a mid-tier card such as the Amex Aeroplan Card at $120 is the better value.

How are the fit scores calculated?

Each fit score is computed from this site’s card data by a fixed formula: four weighted components add to 100 (the card’s earn rate in the category being ranked, its welcome bonus value, its annual fee, and how easy it is to qualify for), with points converted at the typical redemption values on our reward values page. Every table also shows the card’s class-relative card score, which measures the whole card rather than one job. Both methods are on the methodology page.